Private mortgage insurance, commonly known as PMI, allows many qualified buyers to purchase a home without making a 20% down payment. The insurance protects the lender, not the homebuyer, if the borrower stops making mortgage payments. In exchange for that protection, lenders can offer conventional mortgages with down payments as low as 3% to 5% for eligible buyers.

According to U.S. Mortgage Insurers, in 2025, PMI helped more than 800,000 borrowers secure mortgages. Nearly 65% were first-time homebuyers.

“Knowing how PMI works is critical to evaluating the true monthly costs associated with financing and whether the timing is right to purchase a home,” says Tom McCormick, 2026 chairperson of the Greater Milwaukee Association of REALTORS® board of directors and broker/partner of Home Base Realty LLC.

What PMI Does

Most conventional lenders require PMI when a buyer makes a down payment of less than 20%. This requirement generally applies when the loan-to-value ratio exceeds 80%. In simple terms, the buyer has less equity at closing, so the lender assumes more risk. PMI transfers a portion of that risk to a private mortgage insurer.

“I remind homebuyers that PMI isn’t insurance that covers them; it covers the lender if foreclosure happens,” says Beth Jaworski, a REALTOR® with Shorewest. “Getting rid of it as soon as possible makes the most financial sense.”

Buyers can pay for PMI in several ways. Many choose a monthly premium added to their mortgage payment. Some pay an upfront premium at closing, while others use lender-paid PMI, which typically comes with a higher interest rate. The exact cost depends on the loan amount, down payment, credit profile, loan type and insurer pricing. Although PMI premiums do not reduce the principal balance, the coverage makes a smaller down payment possible.

Benefits of Using PMI

PMI’s biggest benefit is that it can put homeownership within reach sooner. A homebuyer who waits until they’ve saved enough money for a 20% down payment could spend years renting while home prices, interest rates and rents change. With PMI, an eligible buyer may be able to purchase with significantly less than 20% down. Purchasing earlier gives homeowners the opportunity to build equity and benefit from their home’s potential appreciation.

A smaller down payment for a home can provide greater financial flexibility. Rather than draining savings, buyers may retain funds for emergency reserves, maintenance, property taxes, insurance deductibles and improvements. That cushion can be especially important after closing, when first-year homeownership expenses sometimes catch buyers by surprise. Purchasing sooner may be valuable in a competitive market where waiting could mean losing out on a preferred home or neighborhood.

When PMI Makes Sense

PMI makes sense when the buyer has stable income, strong credit, manageable debt, and enough cash left after closing for reserves. It can be especially useful when the buyer expects to stay in the home long enough to benefit from ownership and the cost of waiting could exceed the temporary expense of the insurance. Buyers should compare the monthly premium with projected rent, the time needed to save a larger down payment, local home-price trends and the value of keeping cash on hand.

When Saving 20% Down May Be Better

Waiting and building a larger down payment may be the better choice when the additional premium would make the monthly payment uncomfortable, the buyer lacks emergency reserves or job stability feels uncertain. Waiting could be advantageous if the buyer can save quickly, expects home prices to soften or wants a lower payment from day one. A 20% down payment can reduce borrowing costs and provide more equity at closing. Depending on the market and seller priorities, it may strengthen an offer as well.

When to Cancel PMI

Buyers should understand from the beginning when and how the coverage can be canceled. Under the Homeowners Protection Act, borrowers may request cancellation when the loan balance is scheduled to reach 80% of the home’s original value. They generally must be current on the loan, have a good payment history, submit the request in writing and meet other lender requirements.

Jaworski points to several ways homeowners can reach the threshold sooner.

“Especially in the beginning, additional payments create a real advantage,” she says. “Setting up a biweekly mortgage payment system or making extra payments can make a noticeable difference in just a few years.”

Before enrolling in a biweekly payment program, homeowners should confirm that it will result in 26 half-payments – or 13 full monthly payments – each year and determine whether fees apply. Making one additional principal payment annually may offer a simpler alternative.

Rising property values may provide another path to cancellation. When appreciation, improvements or additional principal payments have created substantial equity, homeowners may want to ask their loan servicer whether a new appraisal could support cancellation. Before ordering one, they should confirm the servicer’s requirements and compare the appraisal cost with the potential savings.

A Simple Test Before Choosing

Before deciding, buyers should answer four questions:

  1. Does the full monthly payment, including taxes, insurance, PMI, utilities and maintenance, fit comfortably within my budget?
  2. How long would it take to save 20%, and what could happen to rents, interest rates and home prices during that time?
  3. Will I still have three to six months of reserves after closing?
  4. What is the plan to remove PMI – scheduled amortization, additional principal payments, appreciation or a combination?

PMI is neither good nor bad by itself. It is a financing tool that can help the right buyer purchase sooner without weakening the household budget. A careful side-by-side comparison of the cost, savings timeline, available reserves and long-term goals can show whether PMI opens the right door – or whether waiting for a 20% down payment offers greater financial security.

The REALTOR® Advantage

A REALTOR® is a member of the National Association of REALTORS®, is committed to a Code of Ethics and has the expertise to find the right home for everyone. Look for the “R” to determine if your agent is a REALTOR®.

Locally, the Greater Milwaukee Association of REALTORS® is a 5,500-member strong professional organization dedicated to providing information, services and products to help REALTOR® help their clients buy and sell real estate. Visit gmar.com for more information.


Leave a Reply